Skip to content
Back to blog
SEO

How to Choose an SEO Company: 6 Questions to Ask First

How to choose an SEO company: check case studies, how results are measured, and how changes are explained. Includes Google's 6 questions and red flags.

6 min readSEO
SEO companyhow to choose an SEO companySEO agencySEO consultingSearch Console
How to Choose an SEO Company: 6 Questions to Ask First

An SEO company is a firm you hire to grow your search visibility, and any firm that guarantees a #1 ranking should be screened out. When you learn how to choose an SEO company, check three things first: past work examples, how results are measured, and how changes are explained. In its document on whether you need an SEO expert, Google states that no one can guarantee a #1 spot in Google Search, and it tells you to look for another company if someone does (as of Nov 6, 2026).

Decide whether you need an SEO company first

Before you ask for SEO company quotes, find out where your site is stuck. It is like going to a hospital without knowing what hurts: you cannot tell which department to visit. If you arrive with your symptoms written down, you can judge whether the doctor's prescription makes sense. In the same way, if you know where your site is blocked, you can judge whether a company's proposal fits the problem. Google Search works in the order of finding a page, storing it, and showing it, so the fix depends on the stage that is blocked. This comparison is only an aid to understanding. The real decision follows the official criteria below.

Google suggests that a small local business can try it themselves and should start with the SEO starter guide. The same document says an expert has the most impact when you are building or redesigning a site. If the basic concepts are new to you, read what SEO means and the basic methods first. If you are also looking at ad agencies, see how to choose an ad agency and what to check in the contract.

How to choose an SEO company: 6 questions before you hire

Google's documentation lists questions to ask when you interview a company. The left column is the list from Google's document. The middle and right columns, the answers that reassure you and the answers to avoid, are examples added by MCPY.

What to askA good answer (example)An answer to avoid (example)
Examples of previous workShows before and after results for a similar industryCannot name any client
Compliance with Google Search requirementsExplains that they follow Google Search EssentialsAvoids explaining, calling it "our own method"
Expected results and timingGives a range and a period, with conditionsPromises "#1 within a few weeks"
How results are measuredUses metrics such as Search Console impressions and clicksShows only their own ranking screenshots
Sharing of changesDocuments what changed and whyKeeps the work secret
Interest in your business and competitorsAsks about your business model and competitors firstSells the same package to everyone
Diagram of how to choose an SEO company, summarizing 6 questions to ask before hiring
Six questions to ask in the interview. Source: summarized from Google Search Central documentation.

Google also tells you to check whether the company's past clients were helped, whether it was easy to work with, and whether there were results. You can also ask whether their experience with your industry, your country and city, and overseas sites fits your business. If your site is in Korea, decide in advance whether you also need visibility on Naver, Korea's largest search engine, and put it in the scope. Naver has separate steps such as Naver SearchAdvisor registration, so if you contract only Google work and expect Naver work too, your expectations will not match. The Naver approach is covered in how to build Naver search authority with data.

SEO company red flags: proposals to screen out

The warning signs in Google's documentation are guaranteed #1 rankings, claims of a special relationship with Google or priority submission, companies that do not explain their work plan, and random emails from unknown senders. Google also says not to trust a third-party tool that claims to be approved by Google. Google does not evaluate or endorse such tools.

Also look at what work the proposal lists. Google's spam policies define buying and selling links to raise rankings, link exchanges, links made by automated programs, and mass production of low-value pages with AI and similar tools as spam. If such work is detected, rankings can drop or the site can be removed from search results, and manual actions reviewed by a person are reported in Search Console.

How to choose an SEO company: red flag diagram for guaranteed #1 rankings, bought links, and mass AI content
The difference between proposals to screen out and proposals to accept. Source: summarized from Google Search Central documentation.

The responsibility falls on the site owner, not the company. Google states that the site owner is ultimately responsible for the actions of the company they hire. If work such as link buying is caught, your site suffers. Read how to check backlinks and what counts as link spam before signing, and you will be able to spot those items in a proposal.

After signing, give Search Console access from the lowest level

Google advises giving a company read-only access to Search Console during the audit stage, not write access. Search Console has three user permission levels. An owner can do everything, including adding and removing users. A full user can do most tasks, such as submitting sitemaps and removing URLs. A restricted user can mostly only view data.

The safe order is to start with restricted access and raise it to full access when the work needs it. You keep owner access yourself. To add access, open the property with an owner account, choose Users and permissions in Settings, click Add user, then enter the Google account email of the company's contact and set the permission level. You cannot add an email group. If you also give server access, the company should be able to explain every change. If you do not use Search Console yet, set it up first with how to get started with Search Console.

How to choose an SEO company: diagram of granting Search Console access step by step, starting with restricted
Raise the Search Console access you give a company from a lower level to a higher one.

How to check an SEO company's results

Google advises you to discuss expected results, timing, and how results will be measured with the company in advance. If you put these three things in writing before the contract, you have a standard to compare against later. Google also tells you to check whether the company's recommendations are backed by official Google documentation, and to see whether any AI search optimization advice matches Google's generative AI guide. The simplest method is to ask for the source document behind each task the company recommends.

  1. In the Search Console performance report, compare impressions and clicks for the 28 days before the work started with the 28 days after.
  2. Check whether the search terms the company emphasized increased in the query list, and how the average position changed for those terms.
  3. Get the list of pages the company changed and the document explaining why, then check them against the actual pages.

These three steps are the check order MCPY suggests. At each agreed reporting date, see whether all three are filled in. If impressions are not growing and the changes are not explained, it is time to renegotiate the contract terms. If the work the company reports differs from Google's documentation, ask for their evidence on the spot.

Frequently asked questions

How much should an SEO company cost?

Google's documentation does not give a price standard for SEO companies. Look at whether the proposal states which tasks will be done, how often, and what will be reported, rather than focusing on the monthly fee. Compare quotes from two or three companies for the same scope.

Can I use an SEO company that does not guarantee #1?

Yes. Google says no one can guarantee a #1 spot in Google Search, so not offering a guarantee is normal. Instead, agree on the range of expected results and how they will be measured.

Is an SEO company the same as an ad agency?

No. SEO grows organic visibility in search results, while search ads appear in ad slots and charge you per click. If a company offers both, ask them to separate the costs and reports for the two items.

Found this useful? Share it

Latest posts

Related projects

Get new posts by email

Insights on marketing, analytics, and dev, delivered to your inbox.